EBSA vs School Refusal: Understanding the Difference

There are many different terms that are used to describe a child's absence from school. These terms include "school refusal," "truancy," and "persistent absenteeism." While they all relate to a child's non-attendance at school, they have distinct meanings and implications which are important for all to understand.

The Misleading Term: School Refusal

When a child or young person experiences such intense anxiety that attending school becomes overwhelmingly difficult, this has previously been referred to as ‘School Refusal’, even by different professionals. However, this the term ‘School Refusal’ can be stigmatising and misleading for both parents and students because it suggests that the act of avoiding school is a conscious 'choice' they are making rather than reflecting the extremity of emotion behind this. Their attempts to avoid the school environment is therefore a natural coping strategy, the same as anyone facing an extremely anxiety provoking situation.

The term School Refusal is now widely regarded as not accurately capturing the breadth of underlying psychological distress that children and young people are experiencing. And, worse, ‘School Refusal’ can create a sense of blame, making it seem as if the child is intentionally defying authority or trying to avoid their responsibilities. In reality, many of these children are grappling with significant emotional distress that makes it nearly impossible for them to face the school setting.

"When my daughter started refusing to go to school, I thought she was just being stubborn. It wasn't until much later that we understood the depth of her anxiety. Calling it 'school refusal' didn't do justice to what she was going through."
- Quote from a Parent

 

What is Emotionally Based School Avoidance (EBSA)?

In response to the concerns surrounding the term ‘School Refusal’, alternative terms like Emotionally Based School Avoidance (EBSA), Emotionally Based Barriers to School Attendance (EBSA), Emotionally Based School Non-Attendance (EBSNA), or Anxiety-Related Absence are gaining popularity. While there isn’t yet a consensus on terminology, these terms at least offer a more accurate description that acknowledges the emotional and psychological factors at play.

The terminology we use has profound implications on how we approach solutions. EBSA/EBSNA, by its very nature, elicits a compassionate, empathetic understanding, urging us to look beyond mere absenteeism to the emotional distress causing it.

EBSA/EBSNA is a term that encapsulates the emotional distress that sees a child avoid school, not out of choice but out of necessity to cope. It's a response to underlying anxiety, which can also lead on to associated depression and other challenges over time. For all children and young people, understanding their emotional distress is always the first step towards personalised support. Our aim then is not to get a child or young person to attend school, but to create an environment and resilience factors where they feel comfortable to attend school.

"Using the term 'EBSA' instead of 'school refusal' helps us approach the situation with more empathy and understanding. It reminds us that these children are not just avoiding school; they are struggling with their emotions."
Quote from a Teacher

Truancy: A Different Phenomenon

On the other hand, "truancy" is a distinct concept from EBSA/EBSNA. Truancy typically refers to unexcused absences from school that are not related to emotional or psychological issues. In this case, truancy does often involve a deliberate choice by the child to skip school often to seek something pleasurable. While truancy can be concerning and may have underlying issues which are important in themselves to understand (why does the child/young person value doing X over attending school?), it is not the same as the emotional turmoil that children experiencing EBSA/EBSNA go through.

Accordingly, truancy often arises in older teenagers, without the knowledge of parents, and there is a higher chance of it being related to anti-social behaviour. The narrative of a rebellious teen, who frequently skips school to hang out with older friends and/or play computer games without genuine regard for school is a typical example. Unlike EBSA, truancy does not involve emotional distress. It’s important to note here and at this point that, if you think a child is ‘truanting’, dig a little deeper; the majority of times what may appear like truancy is masking the anxiety which is the driving force for non-attendance.

Persistent Absenteeism: A Broader Perspective

Finally, what is ‘persistent absenteeism’? This is a broader term that simply related to any frequent absence from school, whether it is excused or unexcused, and may or may not be related to emotional distress. It reflects the behaviour, not the underlying needs of the child or young person, and can therefore also include causes from health issues to family problems.

Why Understanding These Terms Matters

These terms matter because they lead to different assumptions of how we should approach and support the child or young person.

A Holistic View

EBSA/EBSNA encourages a holistic view, encouraging us all to understand the emotional needs of the child. It’s not merely about getting the child back to school; it's about addressing the emotional distress that hinders school attendance.

Appropriate Support and Intervention

When we accurately label a child's situation, we can provide them with the right support and intervention. Children experiencing EBSA/EBSNA need a different approach than those dealing with truancy.

EBSA/EBSNA’s emphasis on emotional understanding paves the way for personalised, sustainable support. Each child’s circumstance is unique, necessitating tailored interventions. Through a thoughtful, empathetic lens, we can devise support plans that address the root causes of school avoidance, thereby creating a sustainable path towards regular school attendance.

Reducing Stigma

The term "school refusal" can carry a stigma that may deter parents from seeking help or cause unnecessary shame for the child. Using more precise terms like EBSA/EBSNA can reduce this stigma and encourage open communication.

Collaboration Among Stakeholders

Teachers, parents, and other professionals must collaborate effectively to help a child facing school-related challenges. Clear terminology ensures that everyone is on the same page of supporting them emotionally, working towards the same goal.

Promoting Empathy and Understanding

Using terms like EBSA/EBSNA emphasises the emotional and psychological aspects of the issue, promoting empathy and understanding among all involved parties.

Improved Outcomes

When the focus shifts from punitive measures associated with terms like Truancy, to a more nurturing, understanding approach embodied by EBSA/EBSNA, the outcomes are notably improved. The support becomes about nurturing rather than disciplining, about understanding rather than penalising.

Steering Towards Compassionate Solutions: A Conclusion

The terminology we use matters. The term ‘School Refusal’ may not accurately capture the emotional turmoil that many children face when they cannot attend school due to anxiety or emotional distress. Instead, terms like EBSA/EBSNA offer a more compassionate and precise description.

As parents, teachers, and professionals, our goal should always be to support and understand the children in our care. By using terminology that reflects the reality of their experiences, we can create a more compassionate and effective environment for addressing their needs. Whether it's EBSA/EBSNA, truancy, or persistent absenteeism, let's remember that every child's situation is unique, and our approach should reflect that uniqueness with care and empathy.

The shift towards an EBSA/EBSNA-centric approach not only caters to the emotional well-being of the students but also fosters a nurturing school environment that is conducive to learning and growth. It's an invitation to embrace a more empathetic, holistic approach that beholds the child beyond mere labels, fostering an environment where every child is understood, supported, and guided towards overcoming the emotional hurdles to school attendance. Through this lens, we are not simply addressing non-attendance; we are nurturing resilient, emotionally secure individuals ready to thrive in their own educational pathways.

Reflections

• How does your perception of a child change when you consider their absenteeism as EBSA/EBSNA rather than truancy?
• How can a shift towards an EBSA/EBSNA -focused approach enhance the overall school environment?

FAQ

How can schools effectively address EBSA/EBSNA?

Addressing EBSA/EBSNA necessitates a holistic, empathetic approach. This encompasses educating staff about EBSA, fostering open communication, engaging parents in a collaborative dialogue, and devising personalised support plans to address the emotional distress underlying school avoidance.

What are the key steps in devising a support plan for students exhibiting EBSA?

The formulation of a support plan should entail a thorough assessment of the emotional distress driving school avoidance, engaging a team around the child, and tailoring interventions to address the unique needs of each child.

How does addressing EBSA/EBSNA contribute to creating a nurturing school environment?

Addressing EBSA/EBSNA fosters a compassionate, understanding ethos. It shifts the focus from punitive measures to nurturing support, promoting a school culture where every child is understood, supported, and guided towards overcoming the emotional hurdles to school attendance.

What are the long-term benefits of an EBSA/EBSNA-centric approach?

An EBSA/EBSNA-centric approach not only improves school attendance but cultivates a conducive learning environment. It nurtures resilient, emotionally adept individuals, ready to thrive in the educational landscape and beyond, thus fostering a robust foundation for lifelong learning and well-being.

References

Kearney, C. A. (2008). School absenteeism and school refusal behavior in youth: A contemporary review. Clinical Psychology Review, 28(3), 451-471.

Lyon, A. R., & Cotler, S. (2009). Toward reduced bias and increased utility in the assessment of school refusal behavior: The case for diverse samples and evaluations of context. Psychology in the Schools, 46(4), 379-389.

Maynard, B. R., Heyne, D., Bulanda, J. J., Thompson, A. M., & Pigott, T. D. (2018). Treatment for school refusal among children and adolescents: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Research on Social Work Practice, 28(1), 56-67.

EBSA Schools Training

EBSA Educational Psychologist CPD

Whole Local Authority EBSA Initiative